Dismantled in Two Days: The Haunted Riddle House, Florida

Riddle House

Reviewed by Josh N · Updated November 17, 2026 · How we verify

Most reputedly haunted houses stay where they were built. The haunted Riddle House did not. The Edwardian frame house now standing in Yesteryear Village, a historical park inside the South Florida Fairgrounds in Palm Beach County, Florida, spent its first ninety years several miles away on Acacia Street in West Palm Beach, where it looked out across Dixie Highway at a cemetery. In 1995 it was cut into sections, trucked across town and put back together. That one fact shapes everything a visitor should know about the place, including the ghost stories.

The Riddle House at a Glance

Built: begun July 1, 1905, by workers from Henry Flagler’s hotel crews, using leftover wood.

Riddle House
Riddle House. Photo: 12george1 (CC BY-SA 3.0)

Original address: 327 Acacia Street, West Palm Beach.

Early names: “the painted lady” for its bright colors, then officially “Gatekeeper’s Cottage”, then “City House” from 1914.

Namesake: Karl Riddle, who acquired it in 1920.

Now located: Yesteryear Village, South Florida Fairgrounds, restored to its 1920s appearance.

Television: featured in a 2008 episode of Ghost Adventures on the Travel Channel.

Leftover Flagler Lumber and the Cemetery Across Dixie Highway

The house went up as a side project. Construction crews who had been building Henry Flagler’s hotels started work on it on July 1, 1905, using leftover wood, and the result was colorful enough that locals nicknamed it “the painted lady”. Its formal name was more sober. As Gatekeeper’s Cottage, it housed the keeper of Woodlawn Cemetery, which sat directly across Dixie Highway from the front door.

The cemetery connection is the detail every retelling leans on, and it is genuinely in the record rather than invented later. So is a second one: the house also originally served as a funeral parlor. Whatever a reader makes of that, it is the historical backdrop against which the later stories were told.

Karl Riddle, Recalled by Five Votes

In 1914 the West Palm Beach city government bought the property and it became known as City House. Karl Riddle acquired it in 1920. He was the city’s first city manager and superintendent of public works, and he gave the building the name it carries today.

His tenure ended badly. Riddle was recalled in 1923 by a margin of five votes, and he moved out; the house then served as temporary housing for new city employees. He and his twin brother Kenyon later built houses on a 36 acre property outside the city in 1935, an area that was incorporated as Cloud Lake in 1951 after a vote by residents.

The house kept changing hands. In 1972 the artist Mary Ann Hayes bought it at auction for just over $21,000 and turned it into an art school, the Flagler Arts Center. In the early 1980s Palm Beach Atlantic College, now Palm Beach Atlantic University, purchased it and used it as a dormitory for several years, before scheduling it for demolition to make room for campus expansion.

Sixty Volunteers and a Two-Day Move

Instead of demolishing the house, the college donated it to the Yesteryear Village committee of the South Florida Fair board of directors. The chairman of that committee was John Riddle, nephew of Karl Riddle. Professional movers estimated relocation at roughly $50,000, so John Riddle recruited 60 volunteers and did it another way.

Between August 12 and August 13, 1995, the Riddle House was taken apart. The roof and attic were split in two, and so were the first and second floors. The sections traveled to Yesteryear Village and the building was reassembled there. A $450,000 state historical grant paid to restore it to its 1920s appearance.

What the Record Actually Supports About the Riddle House Ghost

Here the honest answer is short. The documented history of this building gives a reputation for hauntings somewhere to attach itself: a cemetery gatekeeper’s cottage that also served as a funeral parlor, a politician turned out of office, a long run of institutional owners. What that history does not give is a verified death, crime or disaster inside the walls.

The paranormal reputation is tied most firmly to television. The house was featured in 2008 on the ghost-hunting series Ghost Adventures on the Travel Channel, and that broadcast is the reason most visitors have heard of it at all. Anything beyond that, the specific stories told about particular rooms and particular figures, is reported experience circulated by visitors and investigators rather than anything the documentary record establishes. Treat it accordingly.

There is also the structural problem that comes with any relocated building. Boards that were dismantled, trucked and bolted back together in two days are the same boards, but the house is no longer standing on the ground it stood on, and it no longer faces Woodlawn Cemetery. Readers who think place matters in these stories should weigh that. Readers who think the material matters more will weigh it differently.

Finding the Riddle House in Yesteryear Village

The house is no longer a private residence, a dormitory or an art school. It sits in Yesteryear Village, the historical park within the South Florida Fairgrounds in Palm Beach County, restored to how it looked in the 1920s, when Karl Riddle lived there. Check the park’s own schedule before traveling, since access to a site inside a fairground follows the fairground’s calendar rather than ordinary museum hours. The original Acacia Street lot holds nothing to see; the building and its story both moved in 1995.

Address: Yesteryear Village, South Florida Fairgrounds, Palm Beach County, Florida (originally 327 Acacia Street, West Palm Beach)

See Riddle House for Yourself

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Riddle House Yesteryear Village located?

Riddle House Yesteryear Village is located at 327 Acacia Street, West Palm Beach.

Can you visit Riddle House Yesteryear Village?

Riddle House Yesteryear Village is open to the public. Always follow posted rules and respect private property.

Reader sightings

Nobody has reported anything here yet. If you have been, you would be the first.

Report your own visit to Dismantled in Two Days: The Haunted Riddle House, Florida
What happened? Tick anything that applies.

Everything is read by a person before it appears. We publish accounts, not arguments, and we never publish your email.

How haunted is this place?

Be the first to rate

Ghost Tours Nearby

Affiliate links: BeyondHaunted may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.

Nearby Haunted Locations

  1. 1Blue Anchor Pub HauntingFlorida17mi
  2. 2Stranahan House GhostsFlorida41mi
  3. 3Oak Hammock Park and the Devil’s TreeFlorida45mi
  4. 4The I-4 Dead ZoneFlorida57mi
  5. 5Villa Paula in MiamiFlorida61mi
  6. 6Fatty Walsh and the Biltmore Hotel Ghosts of Coral GablesFlorida68mi

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *