The Boiler Room Myth: Haunted Annie Lytle School, Jacksonville

Reviewed by Josh N · Updated October 3, 2026 · How we verify

Few ruins in Florida have a ghost story that the people protecting the building will argue with you about on the record. The haunted Annie Lytle school, properly Public School Number Four, sits boarded and burned out in Jacksonville, hemmed in by interstate ramps, and the group working to save it has publicly called the murder legends attached to it nonsense. That makes this an unusually clean case study in how a rumor outgrows a place.

Quick Orientation on Public School Number Four

What it was: an elementary school, completed in 1918 as Riverside Grammar School and Duval County’s fourth public school house. The words Public School Number Four are inscribed on the building to mark that. It was renamed Annie Lytle Public School around 1950, after Annie Lytle Housh, principal of the earlier Riverside Park School. It closed to the public in 1960, has stood vacant for decades, and was designated a historic landmark by the Jacksonville City Council in 2000. It is private property, and trespassers are arrested.

From a Wooden Fire Hazard to Poured Concrete

The lineage starts with Riverside Park School, built in 1891. It was a boxy wooden-frame building later deemed a fire hazard and structurally unstable, which is a blunt assessment to find in the record of a school full of children. In 1915 Duval County passed a one million dollar bond to put up new brick school houses, one of them to replace Riverside Park School.

Construction began in 1917 to a design by architect Rutledge Holmes and finished in 1918. Most of the new school was built with poured concrete and was designed to withstand anything. That decision is the reason there is still a building to argue about. The shell has outlasted a fire, decades of vandalism and three separate owners with plans for it.

How the Interstates Stranded the School

The school originally overlooked Riverside Park. Then Interstate 95 and Interstate 10 were built, and the construction isolated it from the neighborhood it was made to serve. In 1960 Annie Lytle was permanently closed to the public, and the building spent the next ten years as office space and storage.

In 1980 it sold for $168,000 to the Ida Stevens Foundation, which hoped to convert it into apartments for senior citizens. Federal funding programs meant the renovation never happened. A fire broke out in the vacant building in 1995 and brought the auditorium roof down. In 1999 Foundation Holding Incorporated bought the property intending condominiums, but public outcry led instead to landmark status in 2000. Tarpon IV LLC purchased the building in 2011 for an $86,600 tax deed.

The Janitor, the Boiler, and a Flat Denial

The stories that circulate locally are the lurid kind: a janitor who tortured students in the boiler room, a boiler that exploded and killed children. There is no evidence for any of it. These are myths that grew out of the vandalism and the ruin itself, in the way abandoned institutional buildings reliably attract them.

The Annie Lytle Preservation Group, the property’s sole protector, has put its position in print. In its words: “The boiler never exploded and killed kids. The janitor never killed kids…It’s all nonsense. It never happened.” That is as close to a primary-source rebuttal as a haunted site ever gets. The school is said to be haunted, and trespassers come in attempts to see a ghost or spirit in the abandoned building, but the reported phenomena amount to that: a reputation, pursued by people who climb a fence to look for it.

Why You Should Not Go In

The interior has drawn vandals, homeless people, drug users and graffiti artists, who have covered much of it. The auditorium roof is gone. The Preservation Group warned in a Facebook post in 2019 that trespassers will be arrested if caught on the property, and stressed its close partnership with the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office. Ten people have been arrested.

So treat this one as an exterior. It is a 1918 landmark worth looking at from public ground, stranded in a knot of highway, and the honest version of its ghost story is that the building’s own guardians say there is nothing behind it.

Address: Jacksonville, Florida

See Public School Number Four for Yourself

Sources

• Public School Number Four
• The Story Behind the Creepy, Once-Abandoned Annie Lytle Public School Building
• History
• Ruins of Jacksonville: Annie Lytle Public School
• Reclaiming Jacksonville: Stories Behind the River City's Historic Landmarks
• Wikipedia: Public School Number Four

Ghost Tours Nearby

Specters of the Spanish Moss: Jacksonville Ghost Tour★ 4.1 (28)from $26Mayhem in the Mists A Murder Mystery Ghost Tour★ 5.0 (9)from $30

Affiliate links: BeyondHaunted may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.