The Dude Rancher Lodge Ghost Who Unlocks Stuck Doors

Reviewed by Josh N · Updated August 25, 2026 · How we verify

Most of the stories about the Dude Rancher Lodge ghost describe something helpful rather than something frightening. Staff at this 1950 motor inn in Billings, Montana, say the presence attributed to Annabel Goan, who designed the interiors with her daughter and later lived on site, unlocks doors that have stuck. That is an unusual reputation for a haunted building, and the claim is unusual in another way too: it appears in the property’s own National Register of Historic Places application.

Quick Facts on the Dude Rancher

The Dude Rancher Lodge is a motel in Billings listed on the National Register of Historic Places, built in 1950 with a Hollywood-western theme inside and out and a long list of custom features, most of them original to the building. It has had a single change of ownership, in 1992, and the motel and its attached restaurant are still operating. Rooms are bookable, and the three with the most reported activity are sometimes reserved a year ahead.

Percy and Annabel Goan Break Ground in 1950

The motel was the idea of Percival “Percy” and Annabel Goan, who hired the architecture firm Cushing & Terrell and the Riedesel Construction Company. Everett Terrell drew up the building from the Goans’ conceptualization. They broke ground in April 1950 and opened for business on December 17 of that same year. The result was a two-story “Motor Inn” in a U-shape around a central courtyard parking lot.

Percy came to the project with a track record: before 1950 he had owned a car dealership, a Nehi beverage distributorship and other ventures. The plans drew real press interest at the time, partly because hot water, heat and air conditioning in every room was not yet standard and was considered “novel in several respects.”

Bricks From a Hospital, a School and a Mill

The exterior brick was salvaged from Billings buildings that had recently been torn down, among them the old St. Vincent’s Hospital, the former Washington Public School and the Russell-Miller Milling Company. The mason was instructed to lay the mortar deliberately rough and “rustic,” a technique known as weeping mortar. The rest of the outside walls are mostly cedar.

Inside, Annabel handled the design with help from her daughter: knotty pine paneling, carpet woven with cattle brands, smaller Navajo rugs on the bare floors, rope for stair handrails, and a small home-like lounge with exposed fir ceiling joists and a fireplace. The furniture was custom made in an “Old West” style and the original drapes carried scenes from Montana history. A 1984 remodel swapped the carpet for a similar design and replaced the north wing closets with armoires so the bathrooms could be reworked, but a good deal of the original furnishing survives, especially on the south wing.

The Stirrup Coffee Shop and the Branding Wall

The attached restaurant, the “Stirrup Coffee Shop,” opened in the mid-1950s with custom carpet, tooled oak furniture with cowhide seats and backs, a soda fountain, and a kitchen guests could watch. The carpet and some fixtures have changed since, but the ceiling lights with western images are original, and most of the original tables and chairs are still in service.

A second major remodel in 2000 brought the biggest change to the building. The horizontal neon sign that had stood at the courtyard driveway entrance on North 29th Street was moved to the back entrance, part of the south exterior brick was covered with board-and-batten siding, and a new entrance was built. That new wall became the “branding wall,” carrying real brands from area ranches, some burned in during the motel’s 50th anniversary celebration in 2000 and others added later, up through 2015.

From a Family Corporation to Virginia Carlsen

The Goans formed the Dude Rancher Lodge Corporation in 1949, Percy as president and Annabel as vice-president, with their three grown children, Phil, William and Nancy, as directors holding preferred stock. Local lore holds that five sheep ranchers put up the construction capital; in fact 1,500 shares of common stock were sold to a broad slice of the community, including ranchers, stockmen, merchants, bankers, doctors and private investors.

Percy died in 1962 after a car accident and Annabel took over as president. She converted two rooms into an apartment and lived at the motel from 1973 until 1982, when she moved into an assisted living home; she died there in 1983. The family ran the place until 1992, when the corporation was dissolved. Virginia Carlsen, an engineer who wanted a business of her own, bought the motel that year and still owns it. Of the 53 motels and hotels in Billings as of 2008, the Dude Rancher was one of only 10 still owner-operated.

Room 226, Annabel’s Favorite

The motel’s website identifies room 226 as the most active spot in the building. It was Annabel’s favorite room and still holds all its original furniture. Her grandson lived in it when he took over running the motel after her death. Two neighboring rooms have also drawn reports.

None of that is evidence of anything, and Carlsen herself does not believe in ghosts, though she does sell Halloween package specials. What the record supports is that the belief is long-standing enough to be written into the building’s NRHP paperwork, and that the three rooms with the heaviest reputation for activity are popular enough to be booked as much as a year in advance.

What Staff and Guests Say They Encounter

Annabel is said to “watch over” the place. Her former caretaker, Andrea “Andy” Williams, who worked at the motel, said the presence does helpful things such as unlocking stuck doors. Employees describe dark shapes moving along a maintenance corridor in the basement. Williams also said that in 2013 she began seeing a man in a blue shirt who would walk down a hall toward the kitchen and vanish; the guess among staff is that he is “Bob,” a former restaurant cook known for fixing himself late-night snacks.

Staff and guests alike report lights and televisions switching on and off with no obvious cause, knocking at doors with nobody outside, and sounds and voices in empty rooms. The oddest thread involves children heard running in the halls, which paranormal investigators have attributed to “residual energy” carried in the recycled brick taken from the old school. That is a hypothesis offered by ghost hunters, not a finding. Investigators generally characterize the Dude Rancher’s ghosts as “benign entities… who love their former business, home and place of work.”

Hotel Impossible and the 250 Percent Jump

Business had slipped after 2007, when a wave of new hotel rooms opened across Billings, so in 2012 Carlsen invited the television program Hotel Impossible and host Anthony Melchiorri to look at the operation. The show offered management advice, brought in local contractors to remodel the front desk area and one room over four days, and worked on online booking and marketing. After the July 9 broadcast, online bookings rose 250 percent, and the extra revenue funded a remodel of 14 more rooms within the year. Shortly afterward, local police fought a “full-on firefight” with a local criminal at the motel, another burst of unlooked-for publicity.

Staying at the Dude Rancher

This is a working motel with a working restaurant, not a tour attraction, and it looks much as it did when it was built. Guests who want the most talked-about rooms, room 226 in particular, should plan well ahead, since the three most active rooms are sometimes booked a year out. Visitors more interested in the architecture than the ghost stories will find the branding wall, the original western ceiling lights in the restaurant and the surviving south wing furnishings worth the stop on their own.

Address: North 29th Street, Billings, Montana

See Dude Rancher Lodge for Yourself

Sources

• Good Ole Fashion Chuckwagon
• Join the Branding Wall Party at the Dude Rancher Lodge
• National Register of Historic Places Registration Form (National Park Service)
• Phil Goan
• Montana History Wiki / National Register, Yellowstone
• Wikipedia: Dude Rancher Lodge

More Haunted Hotels

The Pollard HotelGrand Union HotelMany Glacier HotelLa Posada HotelQueen Anne HotelCecil Hotel